This past week I’ve been reading part of a wonderful book I borrowed from my homeroom teacher (who teaches history) called Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong by James W. Loewen. The book discusses how American history is often skewed by textbooks to make our “heroes” seem like perfect people. Sometimes they just omit facts, and sometimes they put wrong ones altogether. Also, the books author remembers his adolescence and mentions that the textbooks are also boring.
Hmm…no wonder we teens hate history so much. The way it’s taught, like a collection of already-known, rote facts, leaves out the mystery of the past. There’s as much left to learn about history as any other subject. They don’t want to tell us anything controversial. It’s more important to be politically correct.
My brother took a good look at this book and said that it’s communist. But here’s what I think is communist: last year, I saw the following essay question on a test: “In minimum 4 sentences and 8 words per sentence, explain why you like the constitution. You may not say that you do not like the constitution.” (That was paraphrased somewhat.) First of all, it’s the content that matters, not how many sentences and words. But most importantly, why must I like the constitution? Now, I do like the constitution, but not everyone does. This is like a much less extreme version of what my parents went through in 20th century Russia: “Class, write a 5-page paper on why Stalin is the best ruler this country has seen and why it is important to practice socialism. You may not express a negative opinion of Stalin and socialism, or else you will be sent to the camps”. Hmm…
Sometimes, my education is like a big “Lies My Teacher Told Me”. About everything. Not just history. This book explains some misconceptions about history. What are other misconceptions? What are other misconceptions in other subjects? Will I ever know?